Interface arguments in ASP.NET MVC


Interface arguments in ASP.NET MVC



I'm in the process of developing an ASP.NET MVC project, and after several weeks of research, I have a pretty good framework in place using StructureMap to register my dependencies at bootstrap time, create my controllers with the correct implementations, a custom model binder for passing data to my controller, etc.

After thinking about the data objects being passed to my controller actions, I began to wonder... should controller actions take in interfaces or concrete types?

It makes perfect sense that when my controller is being constructed by the controller factory, the dependencies should be passed into my constructor as interfaces, but what about the data objects created by the model binder? Should they be registered into my IoC container as well?

In code, it's only a few extra lines to hook it all up so the engineering overhead is pretty low. On the other hand, based on the nature of the framework, I'm not going to need to handle different implementations in the final product. But with everything I've learned about "future-proofing" my code, interface-driven design, designing for testability, loose coupling, and any other buzz words you can think of on this topic, my gut still tells me that interfaces should be the way to go.

I hope I've made some sense in my dilemma. Does anyone have any strong opinions one way or another on this topic?

TIA, -J


Check Checkbox based on value in CSV

1:

linq to sql joining two table
No way. Inserting markup into hidden jqGrid column You wouldn't be solving the problem IoC is meant to solve.. MVC make action link perform a submit Viewmodels should be dumb as dirt. asp.net mvc int property bind exception IoC is good for swapping implementation details. How do I pass a list of integers to an MVC action? Since your view models are dumb what kind of implementation details must you possible swap? View Models also have narrow and non-orthogonal responsibilities very unlike traditional injectable classes like ILogger or IRepository. MVC.net form post/anti forgery . MVC - Changing or adding a class for either 'Html.ValidationMessage' or 'Html.TextBox' IMHO this would be any serious over-engineering and the resulting complexity ( I'd anticipate service location responsibilities in your controllers for edit scenarios ) wouldn't be worth it..


68 out of 100 based on 73 user ratings 628 reviews